Is half of current medical practice just plain wrong? (Essay, JAMA) - PulmCCM
Mar 192012

This post was featured on; an excerpt follows:

An essay in JAMA by Vinay Prasad (Northwestern of Chicago), Adam Cifu (U. of Chicago) and John Ioannidis (Stanford) should be required reading for every medical student, resident, and to pass every board certification exam in any specialty. In my humble opinion.

John Ioannidis became one of my personal heroes with the publication of his great paper in PLoS Medicine, "Why Most Published Research Findings Are False," and its followup Atlantic magazine profile ("Lies, Damn Lies, and Medical Science"). Rather than being nihilistic, Ioannidis's essay is an elegant statistical proof that makes the simple point that bias and error are inevitable, and rampant in the published body of medical literature.

Here they advise us to consider "When To Abandon Ship," i.e., reverse failing medical practice, using the same direct, unadorned, and courageous prose:

How many established standards of medical care are wrong? It is not known. Medical practice has evolved out of centuries of theorizing, personal experiences, bits of evidence, expert consensus, and diverse conflicts and biases. Rigorous questioning of long-established practices is difficult. There are thousands of clinical trials, but most deal with trivialities or efforts to buttress the sales of specific products. Given this conundrum, it is possible that some entire medical subspecialties are based on little evidence...

(Read the rest of the post at

Prasad V, Cifu A, Ioannidis JPA. Reversals of Established Medical Practices. Evidence to Abandon Ship. JAMA 2012;307:37-38.

Liked this post? Get a weekly email update (no spam, ever), and explore our library of clinical guidelines, practice updatesreview articles. and board review questions.

PulmCCM is an independent publication, not affiliated with or endorsed by any other organization, society or journal referenced on the website.

Authors: contribute your work to PulmCCM Journal or in a guest blog post.

  2 Responses to “Is half of current medical practice just plain wrong? (Essay, JAMA)”

  1. Example: Medicare payment for Chiropractic services. Initially banned in the Medicare law, but added by industry lobbyists . Including CT, MRI, etc

  2. I somehow agree with Mr Dr. John Ioannidis as there is a less of intellectualism in the field of medicine and the research in medical sciences is based on the results and symptom based and not on the real mechanism and theory of it.

    I am ARPIT MATHUR a student from INDIA and my uncle DR RAJKUMAR MATHUR ( A UROLOGIST AND LAPROSCOPIC SURGEON AND PROFESSOR ) got HONORARY FRCS (Honorary Fellow of Royal College of Surgeons England) due to his research in a urological treatment which was not possible years ago .

Leave a Comment